Blog and News

Executive search is a retained, research‑driven service for senior leadership roles. You need a methodical process that protects confidentiality, reaches passive leaders, and delivers a shortlist aligned to strategy. Here’s what sets it apart from standard recruiting, what good looks like, and how to judge results.

What is executive search, and how is it different from standard recruiting?

Executive search focuses on C‑suite, VP, Director, and critical heads of function. It is retained, discreet, and relies on original research rather than adverts and inbox responses. A specialist partner maps the market, speaks to passive leaders, tests leadership behaviours and decision style, and manages a multi‑stakeholder process through to onboarding.

Standard contingent recruiting tends to prioritise speed to CVs. Executive search prioritises the right outcome: leadership performance, culture add, and a hire who stays and delivers. The difference shows up in the operating model (retained vs contingent), the depth of market mapping, interview design, reference methodology, and how the partner manages risk, pace, and confidentiality across the process.

When should you use an executive search instead of internal hiring?

Use an executive search partner when the role is senior, sensitive, scarce, or multi‑region, and when confidentiality and stakeholder alignment are critical.

• Stealth replacements where a sitting leader must not be alerted.
• Transformational roles that will change operating models, markets, or teams.
• Scarce skills where the right candidates are passive and well‑tenured.
• Multi‑region remit where cultural fluency and global networks matter.
• High‑impact functions (e.g., CIO, CISO, CTO, Head of Network, SAP Programme Director) where failure is costly.

If you lack time, passive reach, or the ability to run a confidential process across multiple geographies, a retained model often outperforms DIY or standard hiring. Start with a clear success profile and a defined slate date so stakeholders know what to expect. Share your success profile and we can propose stage‑gate dates this week. Contact us.

What sets effective search partners apart?

The best partners run research‑led market mapping, reach passive leaders discreetly, assess leadership behaviours as well as skills, protect confidentiality by design, and commit to transparent stage gates.

How do effective firms map the market?

We do not guess at the market. We build it from first principles. Expect a structured map covering direct competitors, adjacent sectors, partner ecosystems, systems integrators, vendors, and consulting boutiques. We agree the criteria in advance, so everyone aligns on where to search and where not to spend time.

Field notes (what this looks like in practice):

• Target‑company taxonomy agreed at kick‑off (direct, adjacent, vendor/SI, consultancy).
• Exclusions documented upfront and evidence thresholds for longlist entry.
• Adjacency sweeps to find leaders from parallel markets.

Business impact: Clear targeting cuts time to shortlist and raises the interview‑to‑offer ratio.

How do you reach passive leaders?

Senior leaders rarely respond to adverts. Effective search teams use discreet, credible outreach and peer‑level conversation to surface interest. We show proof of access across target geographies and demonstrate response quality at this level. We keep tight narrative control so the brief lands well and your brand is represented accurately.

Field notes:

• Direct approaches plus warm introductions via trusted operators.
• Open with outcomes, scope, and first‑year success profile; screen early for location, compensation, and restrictions.

Business impact: Peer‑level outreach brings leaders who are not on the market, which widens your slate beyond inbound applicants.

How should leadership and culture be assessed?

Skills are table stakes. Effective partners probe leadership behaviours: decision‑making under pressure, stakeholder influence, strategy execution, and team‑building track record. Interviews are scenario‑based and tied to your success profile. We run formal references with a superior, a peer, and a direct report. Culture add is prioritised over culture fit to avoid groupthink.

Scorecard discipline:

• We link behaviours to the success‑profile outcomes and capture structured notes with consistent ratings across interviewers.

Business impact: Linking behaviours to first‑year outcomes reduces mis‑hire risk and improves 12‑month stick rate.

How is confidentiality maintained in senior hiring?

We start under NDA, use project aliases, and control messaging and channels. Confidentiality is the operating standard. We use controlled disclosure throughout. A good partner will outline how information flows, how candidate identity is protected, and how interview logistics avoid market noise.

Controls we put in place:

• NDA coverage for stakeholders.
• Project aliases and neutral calendar invitations.
• Limited‑distribution briefing packs.

Business impact: Controlled disclosure protects brand reputation and prevents premature disruption.

What stage gates should you expect?

You get dates for longlist and shortlist, plus weekly signal reports: outreach volume, response quality, interview status, risks, and decisions taken. When trade‑offs appear (salary bands, location, scope), we document them, agree the path forward, and then adjust the search.

Your weekly update typically includes:

• Progress to longlist/shortlist dates and current pipeline status.
• Market signals (supply, compensation patterns, mobility constraints).

Business impact: Visible signals de‑risk board conversations and let you pivot early.

What does a robust retained search process look like (brief → onboarding)?

The process follows eight disciplined stages.

1. Success profile and brief: Define 12–18 month outcomes, behaviours, scope, reporting lines, KPIs, constraints. Align stakeholders.
2. Market map & longlist criteria: Confirm targets, adjacencies, exclusions, and evidence thresholds. Lock longlist/shortlist dates.
3. Discreet outreach & screening: Peer‑level approaches, qualification against the success profile, early risk checks.
4. Shortlist & interview design: Present evidence‑rich profiles; design scenario interviews that mirror your challenges.
5. Assessment (if used): Keep tools proportionate and tied to outcomes.
6. Referencing & offer strategy: Formal references; structure offers to secure acceptance. Time offers around quarter end to mitigate counter‑offers.
7. Acceptance & pre‑start risks: Plan comms and stakeholder engagement; confirm early wins and onboarding milestones.
8. 30/90/180‑day check‑ins: Measure progress against the success profile and surface support needs.

How do you measure success in a retained search?

Track time to longlist/shortlist, interview‑to‑offer ratio, offer acceptance, slate diversity %, 12‑month stick rate, and hiring‑manager satisfaction.

• Time to longlist / time to shortlist: pace against plan.
• Interview‑to‑offer ratio: slate quality and interview design.
• Offer acceptance rate: narrative, compensation, and role clarity.
• 12‑month stick rate: did the hire stay and deliver?
• Slate diversity %: breadth of perspectives and backgrounds.
• Hiring‑manager satisfaction: structured feedback gathered at each gate.

How to use these signals like a practitioner:

• Trend the ratios week‑on‑week; do not chase single‑week noise.
• When the interview‑to‑offer ratio drifts, fix the brief or the interview design before widening the market.
• Use diversity % as a design constraint early, not a retrospective.

Business impact: Tracking these KPIs lets you fix design issues early instead of widening the market and extending timelines.

What should be in a kick‑off checklist?

Your kick‑off checklist should cover the brief, the market, and the mechanics:

• Success profile and KPIs.
• Stakeholders for calibration.
• Target‑company list and exclusions.
• Constraints (residency, travel, clearances) and compensation bands.
• Outreach messaging and stage‑gate dates.
• Interview design, any assessment tools, and a referencing plan.

Business impact: Arriving with these artefacts shortens discovery and moves you to the first slate faster.

Why choose ITHR for senior leadership hiring?

ITHR in brief: Established with specialist brands, including ITHR Tech, ITHR Telco, and Swan IT, we deliver retained leadership hiring globally.

Domain depth where it matters: Our group houses specialists across Information Technology, Telecom Technology, and SAP & ERP. That means interviews cut to the issues that decide performance: platform strategy, network architecture including 5G and cloud‑native cores, cyber posture, programme delivery (e.g., S/4HANA migrations), and change leadership.

Global reach, consistent standards: We source leadership talent across the UK, Europe, the Middle East & Africa, Asia, and the Americas, with a single quality system and clear stage gates from brief to onboarding.

Confidentiality and control: We run sensitive mandates with controlled messaging, NDA discipline, and careful interview logistics to prevent market noise.

Typical mandates we run:

• CIO / CTO for cloud modernisation and platform strategy.

Explore our executive search capability or see how it works alongside our broader recruitment services. Book a 20‑minute executive search scoping call. Start here.

Brief a confidential search with ITHR

If you’re planning a senior hire, define your success profile and timeline first. We’ll then agree dates to longlist and shortlist, align stakeholders on the market map, and move discreetly to a secure shortlist.

Talk to our team about your brief, or discuss timelines for your next VP/Director hire.

Written by ITHR’s Director of Executive Search

About the author
ITHR’s Executive Search practice delivers retained leadership hires across IT, Telecoms, and SAP/ERP, operating globally with a research‑led, confidentiality‑first methodology and transparent stage gates.