Blog and News

When you hire at senior level, a polished CV and a confident interview are the easy part. Job titles sound impressive, achievements look neat in bullet points, and most shortlists contain people who meet the basic requirements. The real question is tougher: who will actually lead your organisation through the next phase, rather than simply occupy the role?

That is where executive search recruitment becomes valuable. It helps you reach candidates you would not reach on your own and relies on experienced search consultants who analyse the details of a career history and separate genuine leadership impact from well-presented experience.

Over the years, senior hiring conversations that go wrong usually have one thing in common. There is too much focus on the CV and the interview performance, and not enough on the person’s business acumen and leadership.

This blog is for boards, CEOs, founders and senior HR leaders who want a clearer view of how executive search recruitment identifies leaders who appear similar on the CV.

Why don’t CVs and job titles tell you who the real leaders are?

The problem is that CVs and job titles compress a complex career history into a few lines per role. They also miss key traits you care about when you hire leaders: judgement under pressure, ability to build followership, resilience through change and how someone behaves when a plan does not work as expected.

In senior hiring, you often see processes fail when organisations treat the CV as the full story. We look at the same information and ask a different question: what does this career really tell us about how this person leads? This is the type of assessment organisations expect when they work with ITHR's executive search recruitment team.

What do executive search recruiters look for beyond the CV?

Executive search consultants work with leadership roles every day. Over time, they learn to identify patterns in careers and spot signals that point to real influence rather than title inflation.

Track-record signals that show real influence

A strong CV lists responsibilities and shows how a leader changed the organisations they joined.

In senior searches, we look for signs such as stepping into roles where something needed fixing and leaving behind stronger teams and clearer direction. We pay attention to the context too: we check if impact came from leading a function, shaping cross-functional work or influencing at board level.

We also look at patterns across roles. One standout success can be luck. Consistent improvement in different environments usually points to leadership strength you can rely on.

How leaders make decisions

The way a leader decides what to do often matters more than the decision itself. During interviews and conversations, we focus on how candidates describe choices, trade-offs and risks.

We listen for how someone explains why they chose a path and how they adjusted course when facts changed. We look for evidence of strategic thinking rather than reactive activity, and for a habit of learning from decisions rather than defending them at all costs.

How leaders build and align teams

Top leaders rarely succeed alone. They create conditions where other people can perform.

We pay close attention to how candidates talk about their teams. We ask who joined them more than once and how they have developed successors. We look at turnover patterns, team stability and signs that people wanted to work with this leader again in a different organisation.

Signals of change capability

Most executive roles now involve significant change: new markets, restructures, acquisitions or shifts in business model.

We look for evidence that a leader has faced ambiguity and conflict and still delivered progress. We listen for stories where the path was unclear at the start, and for how candidates dealt with resistance and kept stakeholders aligned while things moved.

Culture contribution, not only culture fit

When you hire a leader, you look at what they do and how they affect everyone around them.

We explore how candidates make decisions, set expectations and handle disagreement. We look for alignment with your organisation’s values and operating rhythm and ask how candidates have influenced culture in previous roles. The aim is to understand whether a leader will add something positive to your environment rather than simply blend in.

How does executive search recruitment verify what the CV cannot show?

Spotting patterns is only part of the work. The other half is checking if the information remains consistent when you review it in more detail.

Deep referencing and reverse referencing

References at senior level should go beyond a brief call with a nominated referee. We speak with people who have seen the leader from several viewpoints, such as peers, direct reports and, where appropriate, board members.

We ask for specific examples of behaviour: how the leader handled pressure, how they treated their teams and how they responded when things did not go to plan. We also watch for gaps between what the candidate claimed and what others describe. The detail in those answers often tells you more than the headline result.

In some cases, we will carry out discreet conversations in the market to understand how people in the market perceive a leader beyond their immediate circle. That helps to build a complete view of reputation and effectiveness.

Pattern recognition from years of senior hiring

Because we work on multiple leadership assignments every year, we build a strong sense of what tends to work in different contexts. We have seen how certain profiles perform in different ownership structures and markets at different stages of growth.

That experience helps us notice early when claims feel unrealistic or when a story does not align with what usually happens in similar situations. It also lets us spot less visible leaders whose CVs may not stand out when you first review them, but who have delivered significant impact.

Market and performance context

A leadership role in a market-leading, well-funded organisation looks different to the same title in a turnaround or a heavily constrained environment. We take that context into account.

We ask what resources available and what expectations the board or owners were set. We assess if someone delivered results because conditions were favourable or if they had to overcome real constraints. That context matters when you predict how a leader will perform in your world.

What changes when you work with an executive search partner that can read leadership evidence?

Internal talent teams and hiring managers bring important insight into your organisation, strategy and priorities. Executive search recruitment adds analysis that focuses on leadership evidence across careers, markets and sectors.

An experienced search partner will help you:

• Turn a high level role description into a clear picture of the leader you genuinely need.
• Test if a shortlist contains people with the right kind of impact, not only good titles and well-written CVs.
• Understand the risks and strengths in each candidate’s track record before you plan.

At ITHR, the executive search recruitment team combines sector knowledge with years of senior hiring experience. They examine the CV and other available information, build a balanced view of how leaders behave and perform and set out the strengths and risks in each option so you can decide based on clear evidence.

If you plan to appoint a senior leader and want a partner who can help you compare real leadership evidence rather than rely on limited information from the CV and the interview alone, you can speak with the ITHR team about your upcoming search. The team can then explain how executive search recruitment could support it.